Umm I think you all are talking about 2 different things here…
(going preface this with … its been what 5-6 years so my memory may be a little fuzzy, and as for experience in this…those from Galileo can vouch that I ran multiple FB events among others so I do kinda know what I am talking about)
The harvey event occurred in the zone and the Fishbowl event had its own little area. These are NOT the same thing.
The Harvey event on the outside was one that did not require anything beyond shooting Harvey to begin, did not take 6 full groups or whatever, could be done with 3-4 fairly easy and was more like an easy turkey shoot if every one was maxed or close and had a clue. The loot was substantially less than the FB event in both quality and quantity.
The Fishbowl event took materials to create a fishhook and everything in order to summon/begin, had its own zone / instance area, and required 6 (or more – seems like it was more, I cant remember) full groups of maxed lvl 150 players with the right class balance and tactics and max lvl pm gear available. The loot was substantial as each wave boss dropped stuff and the end boss dropped lots of stuff, and was the best in the game, barring one or two other equal lvl events that also dropped comparable loot.
Sydokun…it sounds like you are talking about the Harvey event which is NOT the fishbowl (FB) event. Now from what little I heard, I didn’t think the FB was implemented or available at this point, not to mention I would be surprised if there were enough max lvl people on or around that could be mustered for that or any of the other big raids. Not to mention, trying an end raid event and not being maxxed out seems to me a little silly, I mean there was a reason they were END game content. Also, you can correct me if I am fuzzy here, but I thought lvl 150 brought a new hull upgrade and I thought lvl 9 shields were substantially larger then lvl 8 (+50% or 100% larger), not to mention the lvl 9 devices should help a lot in mitigation as well. So while you might get toasted as a lvl 122 with lvl 8 shields, you could take multiple hits as a lvl 150 with lvl 9 shields and devices and other equipment. Also, the point of these raids was TEAMWORK…one of the things that this community always seem to have in spades. The point was that you would take big hits, but your healers would juice you up so you could keep going, and in general JE’s didn’t fight – they are a SUPPORT Class, not a front line shoot em class…they primarily jumpstarted you, and acted as markers so you could be pulled out and repaired and healed before you went back in, their low sigs helped to prevent them from getting hit.
In the Harvey event you didn’t need as much coordination. You just had all the groups stack relatively on top of each other and then you beat on the fishies until the mini boss or final boss spawned and then you collected your loot and went on your way. This was definitely meant to bridge the end level gear to the fishbowl and as an extra entertainment that did not require as much time or coordination as the fishbowl did.
In the FB event, the fight required a lot more coordination and planning. You often had 2-3 triage areas set well back in the corners away from the fight to facilitate the repair and healing of the fighters, with the JEs working as go betweens. The JEs and to some extent the PE would warp into the fight to a dead person to jumpstart them, mark them as ready to get repaired, the JDs would pull those jumpstarted folks back to the triage areas and the TTs healing/repairing before the PWs and TWs would jump back into the fight. With the advent of three basically new classes, this dynamic might be modified some, but basically the FB event will probably be much the same. If you don’t have max classes and max gear and lots of coordination, the event will just chew you up and the fishies will eat you for lunch.
Ok well if I left something out or got something switched around let me know but hopefully this will help clarify / clear things up. Regardless, doing any end game event when you ARENT maxxed out, well you should expect the results to be less than stellar, expecting anything else is just silly.
Ps... your poll, I think, is incorrect at least as far as what you are talking about